New roofer vs experienced roofer – does it matter?
**TL;DR:** Experienced roofers offer better quality, faster work, and proper guarantees. New roofers may cost less but risk poor workmanship and structural issues. For peace of mind and durability, hire someone with proven track records. Always check references and insurance before deciding.
## Introduction
Choosing between a new roofer and an experienced one isn’t just about price. Your roof protects your entire home from rain, wind, and weather damage. A poor roofing job can cost thousands in repairs down the line. Experienced roofers bring skills, proven track records, and proper insurance. New roofers might offer lower rates but come with bigger risks. This guide helps you understand what matters when hiring roofing contractors. We’ll explore the real differences and help you make the right choice for your home.
## Does Experience Really Make a Difference to Roofing Quality?
Yes, experience makes a huge difference. Experienced roofers spot problems new ones miss entirely. They’ve worked in different weather conditions and handled unusual roof shapes. They understand how materials age and fail. New roofers follow instructions but lack problem-solving skills when complications arise.
Experienced roofers catch issues like inadequate ventilation or poor water drainage before they cause damage. They know which materials work best for your specific roof pitch and climate. They’ve made mistakes before and learned from them. This experience means your roof gets done right the first time. New roofers are still learning these lessons on your house, which puts your home at risk.
## What Guarantees and Insurance Do You Actually Get?
Experienced roofers provide written warranties on their work, typically 10 to 15 years. They carry liability insurance and employer’s liability cover. New roofers often lack these protections or offer shorter guarantees.
If something goes wrong with an experienced roofer’s work, you’ve got recourse. You can claim on their insurance or their warranty. New roofers might disappear if problems emerge. They’re less likely to have professional indemnity insurance protecting you. Always ask for proof of insurance before work begins. Check whether they’re registered with the Federation of Master Builders or similar bodies.
## How Much Faster Will an Experienced Roofer Work?
Experienced roofers complete jobs 30 to 40 percent faster than new ones. A three-day job might take five days with an inexperienced roofer.
Speed matters because your home stays exposed to weather during the work. Faster completion means less disruption to your family. Experienced roofers work efficiently without cutting corners. They’ve developed systems over years of work. They also manage unexpected problems quickly without stopping progress. Faster work means lower labour costs overall, sometimes offsetting higher hourly rates.
## What About Cost Differences Between New and Experienced Roofers?
New roofers typically charge £150 to £250 per day. Experienced roofers charge £200 to £350 per day. The difference seems significant until you factor in speed and quality.
A simple roof repair might cost £400 from a new roofer or £600 from an experienced one. But the experienced roofer finishes in two days instead of three. More importantly, you won’t need repeat visits to fix mistakes. New roofers sometimes underprice work, then rush through it. This leads to leaks, poor fitting, and costly repairs within months. Experienced roofers price fairly based on quality outcomes. Your initial saving disappears fast when you need expensive fixes.
## Should You Ever Hire a New Roofer?
Yes, if they’re properly supervised and priced accordingly. New roofers working under experienced contractors can be excellent value. They bring fresh energy and enthusiasm to their work.
The key is ensuring they’re properly trained and supervised. Don’t hire a brand-new roofer as your sole contractor. Consider them only if they’re part of an established company with oversight. Price them lower than experienced roofers. Ask specific questions about their training and experience. Request references from previous customers. Check how long they’ve actually been in the roofing business.
## Conclusion
Hiring an experienced roofer protects your home and wallet long-term. Their speed, quality, and guarantees justify slightly higher costs. New roofers have a place, but only with proper oversight and realistic expectations. Don’t let low prices tempt you into poor decisions about your home’s most critical feature. Your roof is too important for bargain hunting. Find a qualified roofer near you by searching our free UK directory today.
## FAQ
**What qualifications should a roofer have?**
Look for NVQ Level 2 or 3 in roofing, membership with Federation of Master Builders, or NICEIC registration. They should carry full public liability insurance and employers’ liability insurance.
**How long do experienced roofers typically work?**
Many experienced roofers have been working 10 to 20 years professionally. Some establish their own businesses after years as apprentices. More experience generally means better results.
**Can a new roofer get better over time?**
Absolutely. Everyone starts somewhere. Ensure new roofers work under supervision and have proper training. Many become excellent after five years of dedicated work.
**What’s the average roof repair cost in the UK?**
Simple repairs cost £300 to £600. Full roof replacement ranges from £3,000 to £10,000 depending on size and materials. Get multiple quotes for comparison.
**How can I verify a roofer’s experience?**
Ask for references from previous customers. Check Google reviews and Trustpilot ratings. Request proof of insurance and qualifications. Ask how many similar jobs they’ve completed.